
When the Pope tells you to pipe down and listen for a change, it’s hard to ignore.
In his message for World Communications Day released yesterday, he noted that in this age of social media and online connectivity, all too often we are talking instead of listening, being thrown information instead of becoming engaged with it and not making enough room or time for a silence – whether in thought or otherwise – that is all too necessary to focus on truly important questions: “The process of communication nowadays is largely fuelled by questions in search of answers. Search engines and social networks have become the starting point of communication for many people who are seeking advice, ideas, information and answers. In our time, the internet is becoming ever more a forum for questions and answers – indeed, people today are frequently bombarded with answers to questions they have never asked and to needs of which they were unaware.”
I find myself around this all the time. As great as it is to know that Twitter near broke when the Giants scored that crucial field goal on Sunday and that social media activity spiked when President Obama had his stand-up comedy moment during last night’s State of the Union address with the “spilled milk” joke, but all too often I find myself asking, “What do I do with this information?” and more selfishly, “What does it mean to me?” Where is the line between strangers just throwing up thoughts in 140 characters or less and an actual conversation? It is contingent upon my participation? Like the Pope says, questions in search of answers.
Today is my birthday and if there is one thing you learn with each passing year it’s that less is more. One great, expensive coat is better than a dozen cheap scratchy ones; the one best friend you can call up in the middle of the night trumps 60 Facebook friends; one delicious meal is better than 10 items from the dollar menu. Actually, I might be unsure about that last one.
The same, I have found, goes for social media, but it’s a little more complicated. While I pride myself on being dedicated to my social media presence through this blog, my style blog, Twitter, Facebook, Formspring, Polyvore, LinkedIn, Vimeo, and Google+, just keeping up with my stable of passwords is exhausting, never mind making sure that I’m keeping up with everyone else’s online life – I have my own frakked Internet identity to deal with! Integrating these accounts with each other seems a bit self-defeating: I use Twitter for news, quips and observations on the fly; Facebook to send messages to fans; Polyvore for collages to post on my Tumblr… you get the picture. “Less” isn’t necessarily “more” if it means mitigating your reach, but “more” also means fracturing your attention towards a million outlets in order to keep up. And with a new social media network popping up what seems like every other week (or, frankly, every other day), it’s hard to not wonder just what it’s all for. The more connected we are, the more disconnected we become with each other and, to an extent, ourselves.
What the Pope doesn’t directly talk about in his message but what I think he might be implying is that with the bombardment of information and answers to questions we have never asked, we have to ask ourselves what that information means to us when we receive it. Unfortunately, what we care to know and know about these days isn’t really a matter of our choice. Furthermore, we should make decisions about whether we hang on to the information we get and let it take up what I like to call “mental bandwidth” or do we just process it in the moment, let it go and leave time and room for a true dialogue.
Which isn’t to say I don’t love social media, apps and being plugged-in all the time. I am an information junkie, which is partly why I do what I do in the first place. Twitter is my most frequently checked source for breaking news; I text, email, watch videos, leave messages on Facebook through my smartphone all day long. Part of my morning ritual involves brushing my teeth while listening to Morning Edition playing on my iPad. That woman with the oversized sunglasses, walking-and-texting in the Target parking lot? That’s me, the multi-tasking pedestrian you almost backed into with your car. Oops.
Social media is here to stay but I believe the way we use it is still evolving. To make it more meaningful and less noisy, maybe we should resolve to curate the conversation instead of adding to the Bad First Date Syndrome that plagues so many channels, with its endless stream of one-way talking-tos. And then let’s make sure we relish the sound of silence. After all, the Holy See is asking it of us and who am I to say no to the guy who has G-d on speed dial?